Otmar Issing, former member of the ECB (European Central Bank) board, and president of the Institute for Financial Studies, which is perilously close to the Daily Mash's "Institute for Studies" is in an uncompromising mood on the subject of Greece getting a bailout from the ECB, et al.
"It is certainly true that this is a decisive moment for Emu – but for the opposite reason. Greece will continue to receive support from several European Union funds. But financial aid from other EU countries or institutions that amounted, directly or indirectly, to a bail-out would violate EU treaties and undermine the foundations of Emu. Such principles do not allow for compromise. Once Greece was helped, the dam would be broken. A bail-out for the country that broke the rules would make it impossible to deny aid to others.
It seems that quite a number of observers have forgotten what Emu is, and what it is not. The monetary union is based on two pillars. One is the stability of the euro, guaranteed by an independent central bank with a clear mandate to maintain price stability. The other is fiscal solidity, which has to be delivered by individual member states. Member countries are still sovereign. Emu does not represent a state; it is an institutional arrangement unique in history. (Maybe there's a reason for that, like it's a real bad idea? - Hamish)
In the 1990s, many economists – I was among them – warned that starting monetary union without having established a political union was putting the cart before the horse. Now the question is whether monetary union can survive without such a political union. The current crisis must be handled in such a way as to produce a positive answer. The viability of the whole framework – nothing less – is at stake."
Well, I would say that there is a stark choice: take over Greece at gunpoint effectively, and run it economically in a way that, to say the least, it has not chosen to run itself, or give them loads of dosh from the Germans, who will fight it all the way, and probably win, because that's what the law actually says. Which means that what will actually happen is nothing, and so Greece will default, the Euro will go down the toilet, and the knock on effect of this lot will take down the exposed countries, in this this case France, Germany, and... bugger... Switzerland.
Comment from the Wall Street Journal worth a read, for this sentence alone:
"No wonder European leaders felt unable to leave Greece to the mercy of
the markets. But in offering support, they are merely following a
familiar pattern established during the crisis of shifting
responsibility for funding the global debt pile from credit markets to
the banks, from banks to sovereigns and now from weak sovereigns to
stronger ones. Once this transfer is complete, the debt pile really
will have nowhere else to go."
Really, it's a multinational version of Gresham's Law, with bad money driving out, or at least absorbing, the good money. In case you are feeling all tin-foil-hatty at this point, you might like to start examining the serial numbers on your Euros, because in theory they all come from the different countries. (not that legally it makes a blind bit of difference, as money is fungible.)
Enjoy the show, as I always say, you've paid a lot for the ticket.